Eagles vs. Rams: Head official assigned to Divisional Round matchup has not been favorable towards Philadelphia

With the Eagles vs. Rams divisional round matchup just days away, we now know the head official who will be making calls during the contest, Shawn Smith.


By his name alone you probably have no idea who it is, so I’ll refresh your memory.

Eagles’ Unfavorable Record Under Shawn Smith

Philadelphia has endured some head-scratching moments when Smith’s crew has been in charge. Since 2023, the Eagles have played three games under Smith’s watchful eye and have come up short in all of them. Most notably, the Week 16 loss to the Washington Commanders still lingers in fans’ minds. That game featured a highly controversial ejection of safety C.J. Gardner-Johnson—a decision many believe was unwarranted and altered the course of the contest.

I hate blaming officiating for losses, players and coaches bear the primary responsibility for wins and losses. But the impact of officiating cannot be understated.

Eagles fans have seen questionable calls stall offensive drives or gift scoring opportunities to opponents. The frustration lies not in losing, but in the perception that external factors—like inconsistent officiating—can tip the scales unfairly.

Officiating Woes in the NFL This Season

To be fair, the Eagles are not alone in their frustration with officiating this year.

Across the NFL, fans and analysts alike have criticized the league for its inconsistent officiating. Whether it’s missed penalties, dubious roughing-the-passer calls, or unclear explanations from officials, the 2024-2025 season has been riddled with controversy.

In a sport as fast-paced and physical as football, mistakes are inevitable, but the stakes are higher during the playoffs, where every call is magnified.

What the Eagles Need on Sunday

For the Eagles, the recipe for success against the Rams lies in controlling what they can. Jalen Hurts and the offense will need to capitalize on their opportunities, while the defense must find ways to disrupt Matthew Stafford and the Rams. Regardless of the officiating, the Eagles must focus on executing their game plan with precision and discipline.

That said, all Eagles fans ask for is a level playing field. If the Rams prove to be the better team on Sunday, so be it. But let the players, not the referees, decide the outcome of this pivotal playoff matchup. Fairness and consistency should be the standard, especially in a game with so much on the line.

While it’s not fair to accuse Shawn Smith or his crew of bias, history suggests that strange occurrences often follow them when officiating Eagles games. Fans’ skepticism is understandable, but the focus must remain on the team’s performance.

As the Eagles take the field this Sunday, all eyes will not only be on the players but also on the men in stripes. Philadelphia’s playoff hopes hang in the balance, and fans will be watching closely to ensure that this game is decided on merit rather than controversy. Here’s to hoping for a well-officiated contest and an Eagles victory.